Why Developers Are Turning to Adaptive Reuse: The Economic Alternative to New Construction

In today’s rapidly evolving market, commercial developers face critical decisions about how to best utilize land and resources. Adaptive reuse—the process of repurposing existing buildings for new uses—has emerged as a compelling alternative to new construction. For over 50 years, WMF has worked with our clients to help them realize the benefits of adaptive reuse and why it should be a key consideration for every project. 

Sustainability: Driving Eco-Conscious Development 

The first advantage of adaptive reuse is that it minimizes environmental impact by repurposing existing structures instead of demolishing them. By retaining core elements such as foundations, walls, and roofing, developers reduce construction waste and conserve embodied energy—the energy used in the original production and construction process. In contrast, new construction requires extensive resource extraction, material production, and transportation, which contribute heavily to carbon emissions. Choosing adaptive reuse aligns with sustainable development goals and demonstrates environmental responsibility. Cost efficiency through sustainability can be found in multiple ways, here are some examples:  

  • Adaptive reuse can reduce landfill contributions by redirecting millions of pounds of usable materials away from landfills, generating potential savings of up to 20-30% in the waste management portion of construction costs. Implementing detailed waste management plans can reduce on-site waste generation, optimize material usage, and promote responsible disposal practices, leading to significant savings.  
  • Salvaging and repurposing architectural elements from existing structures can preserve historical character and reduce the need for new materials, resulting in potential savings of up to 10-20% in labor, material, and manufacturing costs. 

 

Many downtowns across the country face decaying buildings like the Mercantile Building. However, its renovation allowed it to accommodate retail, commercial, and residential space. Common areas were improved with a new elevator and the building shell received masonry restoration and new energy-efficient windows. Core system updates in mechanical, plumbing, and electrical allow the building to achieve high-performance metrics.

One of the most attractive aspects of adaptive reuse is its potential for cost savings. By leveraging existing materials and infrastructure, developers can significantly reduce expenses on materials and labor. Studies indicate that adaptive reuse can yield construction cost savings of up to 20-30% compared to new construction. These financial benefits enhance project profitability while optimizing resource allocation. 

Preservation of Heritage and Community Identity 

Adaptive reuse fosters a connection with the past by preserving the historical and cultural value of existing buildings. Repurposed structures often retain elements of their original design, creating spaces with character and authenticity that resonate with tenants and customers. In contrast, new construction frequently lacks the depth of identity and storytelling that a repurposed building can provide. Adaptive reuse can strengthen community engagement and pride by honoring local heritage. 

Often, adaptive reuse offers developers a unique opportunity to acquire urban in-fill lots at a reduced rate while optimizing location. Urban in-fill lots, often overlooked or underutilized, can be transformed into valuable assets through adaptive reuse. By repurposing existing structures on these lots, developers can capitalize on prime locations within established urban areas, enhancing accessibility and convenience for tenants and customers. This approach not only reduces acquisition costs but also leverages the inherent advantages of urban settings, such as proximity to transportation hubs, commercial centers, and community amenities. Adaptive reuse thus provides a cost-effective and strategic solution for developers looking to maximize the potential of urban in-fill lots while contributing to the revitalization of city landscapes. 

 

To expand its presence downtown, Penn State Altoona acquired a former retail clothing store and retrofitted the building to support academic use. In partnership with a local business leader, the Business School transformed the space into a center focused on fostering entrepreneurship and incubating successful ventures that connect the university with the greater Altoona community.

Accelerated Project Timelines 

Adaptive reuse can reduce project timelines compared to new construction. With much of the framework and foundational work already in place, developers can bypass some of the extensive planning and construction phases required for a completely new build. This allows businesses to occupy the space and begin operations more quickly, meeting market demands with greater agility. 

Municipalities often offer various benefits to developers for adaptive reuse projects. These benefits can include financial incentives, regulatory flexibility, and support for sustainable development. Additionally municipalities may provide subsidies to help offset renovation costs, especially in small towns where sales and rental values limit options. Incentives may include: 

  • Tax Credits and Abatements: Many cities offer tax credits or abatements to developers who undertake adaptive reuse projects. These incentives can significantly reduce the financial burden of renovation and make projects more viable. 
  • Grants and Subsidies: Some municipalities provide grants or subsidies to support the costs associated with adaptive reuse. These funds can be used for various aspects of the project, including environmental remediation, structural improvements, and energy-efficient upgrades. 
  • Zoning and Regulatory Flexibility: Municipalities may offer flexibility in zoning regulations to facilitate adaptive reuse. This can include relaxed parking requirements, expedited permitting processes, and allowances for mixed-use developments. 
  • Historic Preservation Incentives: For projects involving historic buildings, states, counties, and local municipalities often provide additional incentives to preserve and restore these structures. This can include grants, tax credits, and technical assistance to ensure that the historical integrity of the building is maintained.  

 

After Our Lady of Mercy was closed after their parish reorganization, WMF stepped in to provide the church’s new clients with an adaptive reuse space of their corporate offices. According to MCM Company, Inc., the developer of this project, “The property, previously on the property tax role, generates $38,000 in new property taxes annually.” This $4.8 million redevelopment leveraged $1.55 million in Federal and State Historic Tax Credits. To qualify for these incentives, properties must be listed on the National Register of Historic Places either individually or as contributing structures within a designated Historic District.

These benefits not only make adaptive reuse projects more financially attractive but also contribute to the sustainable development and revitalization of urban areas. 

WMF: Leaders in Adaptive Reuse Solutions

Weber Murphy Fox has a proven track record of delivering award-winning adaptive reuse projects that seamlessly blend historic preservation with modern functionality. For example, the firm’s renovation of the Gitnik Manse at Gannon University transformed a historic building into a vibrant, multi-functional space for academic and social gatherings. By prioritizing sustainable materials, energy-efficient systems, and innovative design, WMF preserved the building’s historic charm while meeting contemporary needs. 

 

One of the aspects of the project at Gitnik Manse involved transforming private offices to conference rooms and large group instruction rooms to make the spaces within the building more useful for students and faculty.

 

Another notable project is 1128 State Street, a recent award-winning adaptive reuse development. This project exemplifies WMF’s commitment to excellence by transforming a historic structure into a modern, functional space while preserving its architectural integrity. The recognition it has received underscores WMF’s ability to deliver innovative solutions that balance sustainability, community impact, and design excellence. 

 

1128 State Street before and after its adaptive reuse project.

 

WMF’s interdisciplinary approach ensures that each project is tailored to the unique goals of its clients. From concept development to execution, the firm integrates architecture, interior design, and planning to create spaces that are not only functional but also inspiring. With decades of experience and a commitment to excellence, WMF continues to set the standard for adaptive reuse in commercial development.

A Strategic Approach to Commercial Development  

For commercial developers seeking sustainable, cost-effective, and community-centric solutions, adaptive reuse offers a robust alternative to new construction. By embracing this approach, developers can reduce costs, enhance environmental stewardship, and deliver unique spaces that retain cultural and historical significance. As market demands increasingly value sustainability and authenticity, adaptive reuse represents not only a practical choice but also a visionary one. 

Contact Us

To learn more about how adaptive reuse can align with your commercial development goals, reach out to us for consultation and project planning. 

Related Articles

WMF Awarded Placemaking Project of the Year at the NAIOP Awards of Excellence

PSU Glenhill Gardens On May 7th, the NAIOP Northern Ohio Chapter honored WMF with the prestigious Placemaking Project of the …

Read More

2024 Building Excellence Award MBA: Erie Hall

On February 28th, 2025, the Master Builders’ Association of Western Pennsylvania (MBA) published their 2024 Building Excellence Awards where WMF’s …

Read More

Funding a Public School Project in 2025

Peters Township High School   The Evolving Landscape of Facility Reimbursement As we enter 2025, the future of state funding …

Read More